The score for “Wanted,” playing at the Grand Central Theatre, carries a richness that should elevate the show beyond its messy narrative. But under Cassandra Webb’s direction, it falls flat where it matters most – Act One. Ay, bendito, but did they really have to make such baffling choices?

Let’s start with the positives. Solea Pfeiffer and Liisi LaFontaine are absolute dynamite as Mary and Martha Clarke, Black twin sisters who pass for white in 1890s Texas and become vigilantes. Their chemistry is one of the show’s highlights; the way they mirror each other’s movements on stage makes you believe that these characters can’t be separated, even by society. And oh, those voices! When they sing duets, it feels like a divine intervention, the harmonies swelling over you like waves in a stormy sea.

The set design is another triumph – towering cacti and an imposing Texas landscape backdrop make for a striking stage picture that’s worthy of any Western film. The lighting designer, a genius named Carlos Soto, has crafted moments where the light casts long shadows on the actors during crucial scenes, adding layers of depth to their performances.

But let’s get back to what makes this show stumble: Act One. Mija, it’s a mess. Director Webb seems to have conceded to an overly convoluted sequence that introduces Mary and Martha’s pastiche of identities in such a way that you’re left scratching your head instead of holding your breath with anticipation for the climax. The central secret – I don’t mean to be dramatic about it, but really, what was going through their minds? – is introduced so casually that by the time the confrontation happens at the end of Act One, which should have been electric with emotion and tension, the audience is just…there. They’re not breathing. Not because they’re awe-struck or moved, but simply confused.

The revival’s willingness to take risks feels more like a gamble here than an inspired creative choice. And yet, in the second act, Webb redeems herself somewhat by allowing the characters room to grow and evolve. It’s almost like she decided halfway through that maybe there was something of a story here – worth telling and worth watching.

You should see this show for Liisi LaFontaine’s performance alone; it’s the kind of raw, candid depiction that makes you forget about the script for minutes at a time. Get there before they close, but leave your patience behind because Act One is still figuring itself out. Revivals this willing to take a swing are rarer than people think, and I appreciate Cassandra Webb for taking on what could have been an impossible task. Estamos aquí.