Director Elena Sandoval’s production of The Midnight Masquerade at the Astor Theatre is a promising idea that falters under her directorial missteps. She attempts to merge the elegance of 18th-century Viennese court with the boldness of modern cabaret, creating an intriguing concept, but it falls apart in execution.

Let’s start with what works: when Isabella Rodriguez performs as Lola, the showstopper that she is designed to be, the audience sighs collectively. Her voice has that quality that great musical theater voices have, where the technique disappears behind the pure emotion and power of her song. “Midnight Waltz”, it’s a number that should stay with you long after curtain call.

But Sandoval’s direction doesn’t give Rodriguez (or anyone else) much room to breathe until Act Two. The set design by Alberto Santos, which incorporates moving columns and mirrors galore, is visually arresting but often becomes a distraction instead of an asset. In one particularly egregious scene transition, the entire stage rotates with such excessive flair that it’s hard not to question its necessity.

The first act is a mess, mija. I don’t mince words because there isn’t much more to say. The pacing drags and Sandoval seems uncertain about her vision for this space where time periods collide rather than coexist comfortably. It feels like an effort to make the staging match the ambition of the concept, but without a solid foundation, it’s just another layer of confusion.

Yet, when we return from intermission, there’s improvement. The lighting by Felipe Espinosa gains confidence in its second half, and the choreography by Maria Gomez is far more integrated and effective post-interval. There’s an energy that finally aligns with the intention behind the costumes crafted by Rosario Martinez, which are themselves a feast for the eyes.

The audience was breathing, though it took too long to get there. By the time we were fully engaged, and yes, Midnight Masquerade does eventually earn its keep, almost an entire act had passed in mediocrity.

So why am I still giving it three stars? Because the second act is a renaissance of sorts for this production. You should see this show; you should see it because the lead performance by Isabella Rodriguez is something special, and because Act Two manages to create the kind of atmosphere that makes you feel like you’re eavesdropping on a grand secret instead of watching from a fixed seat.

Look, revivals are inherently precarious endeavors. This one needed clear direction from the start to make the most of its ambitious fusion of eras. The second act’s success doesn’t quite salvage what came before it, but it does offer us a glimpse into how this show could have been better served. Revivals like these are rare jewels when they work; we should be grateful for the moments where they do. Give The Midnight Masquerade another chance if you’re not easily deterred by an uncertain start. It’s worth finding out what it could become with a bit more polish. Estamos aquí.